Point Counterpoint: Is Addiction a Disease or a Choice? Drug Rehab Options

Regardless, however, of which estimates are correct, the absolute number of current and former addicts is very large. However large that population may be, research reliably confirms that only a relatively small percentage, 25% or less, of those meeting criteria for drug abuse or dependence ever seek and receive treatment. The present paper is a response to the increasing number of criticisms of the view that addiction is a chronic relapsing brain disease. In many cases, we show that those criticisms target tenets that are neither needed nor held by a contemporary version of this view. With regard to disease course, we propose that https://kinozavr.com/2008/09/22/3.htm viewing addiction as a chronic relapsing disease is appropriate for some populations, and much less so for others, simply necessitating better ways of delineating the populations being discussed. We argue that when considering addiction as a disease, the lens of neurobiology is valuable to use.

  • Instead, our focus should shift toward understanding, compassion, and connecting people with quality care.
  • However, by recognizing it for what it really is, medical professionals can develop treatment plans that are more effective for helping their patients.
  • The authors outlined an agenda closely related to that put forward by Leshner, but with a more clinical focus.
  • Examination of the research cited (Hasin, Stinson, Ogburn, & Grant, 2007; Stinson, Grant, Dawson, Ruan, Huang, & Saha, 2005) however, does not appear to support that estimate.
  • Viewing addiction solely as a matter of choice may stigmatize those who are struggling and hinder efforts to provide effective support and treatment.

The Biopsychosocial Model of Addiction

  • This means that activities that do not cause pleasure but provide relief from negative feelings also present a strong habit-forming risk.
  • Treatment for addiction can include a combination of therapy, medication-assisted treatment, and support groups.
  • This means that almost anything can potentially lead to an addiction, be it taking drugs, eating, or simply spending time on the internet.
  • Unfortunately, at the very same time, it prods people to see themselves as hapless victims of a process beyond their control.
  • Over the last few decades, neuroscience, pharmacology and psychology have also focused on gaining a better understanding of the physical side of addiction.

What we do today could prevent anyone else from starting down the same dark path. On the opposite side of this debate, those who believe chemical dependency is a choice point to research and reports that label addiction as a behavior. For example, if addiction is a disease, then you must contract it at some point, and then you have it, and then you get treatment, and if the treatment works, then you’re cured.

is addiction a disease or choice debate

Drug Addiction: Choice Or Disease?

is addiction a disease or choice debate

Thus, he concluded that alcoholism can simply be defined as changes in structure or function of the body due to drinking that cause disability or death. A disease label is useful to identify groups of people with commonly co-occurring constellations of problems—syndromes—that significantly impair function, and that lead to clinically significant distress, harm, or both. This convention allows a systematic study of the condition, and of whether group members benefit from http://icqspeak.ru/vse-dlya-vkontakte/tekstovye-kartinki-vkontakte/281-tekstovye-kartinki-vkontakte-na-stenku-na-stranicu.html a specific intervention. Recognizing addiction as a disease does not absolve individuals of responsibility for their actions.

is addiction a disease or choice debate

A brain disease? Then show me the brain lesion!

Addiction has a high risk of relapse.2 Brain change caused by prolonged substance use can trigger intense cravings, making it hard to resist using again, even if you’ve been sober for awhile. This is why addiction treatment centers often address relapse upfront by building relapse prevention planning into their programs. Choice arguments are also unable to account for the role of heredity in a person’s risk factors for developing an addiction. Once again, if it were solely choice based, addiction would affect each person as an individual and their family history would play no significant role. Behavioral researchers like Dr. Lewis try to argue this by acknowledging that the brain does change during addiction, but they view it as a situation like playing with clay.

is addiction a disease or choice debate

We readily acknowledge that in some cases, recent critiques of the notion of http://webintheblog.org/hotel-review-brockencote-hall-worcestershire-2 addiction as a brain disease as postulated originally have merit, and that those critiques require the postulates to be re-assessed and refined. In other cases, we believe the arguments have less validity, but still provide an opportunity to update the position of addiction as a brain disease. Our overarching concern is that questionable arguments against the notion of addiction as a brain disease may harm patients, by impeding access to care, and slowing development of novel treatments. One perspective on drug addiction posits that it is fundamentally a result of personal choices.

  • First, people may appear to remit spontaneously because they actually do, but also because of limited test–retest reliability of the diagnosis 31.
  • These factors can also make it more difficult for individuals to recover from addiction.
  • One of the most common signs for determining if someone is as risk for addiction is to uncover whether there is a history of past addiction in their family.
  • This disease model underscores the compulsive nature of addiction, driven by neurological changes, making it challenging for individuals to abstain without professional help.
  • Even years after being sober, a person who was once an addict will be at a higher risk for drug abuse than their peers who were never addicted.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *